1 year old, 37 lbs, training is coming along nicely. This one has big range and run, it will be interesting to see her in a grouse woods:
Ted
Ted,
What a gorgeous girl. I want a new 4 legged hunting buddy so bad I can hardly stand it.
I have never owned nor hunted with a "big range and run" dog. Is that a characteristic that you prefer? How does that play out in thick cover?
Bill,
There are many opinions on range and run. I am no expert, but, I know what works for me, and has worked for me in the past.
Setters and English pointers, are air scenters-they locate the bird from the bird's scent in the air. ALL other dog breeds are ground scenters, and locate the bird's scent on the ground. Air scenters should be able to cover more ground, quicker, and at further range than other breeds. I believe they can and do find birds that ground scenters miss, too. But, my experience has been, if a setter does not have the natural ability to work off a good distance from you (range) at a good clip (run) that trait can't be developed in that dog. A dog that has the trait can and should be able to learn to moderate both range and run in heavier cover. Pointers and setters should not be "boot polishers", dogs that work at or near your feet.
I had a Gordon Setter who could work in closer in heavy grouse cover, and also burn a field and lock up on point on a pheasant 125 yards out. I had an English Setter that really couldn't. I also had experience with Irish Setters that had, or didn't have, the trait. That is not to say the dogs that lacked range and run didn't turn out to be OK bird dogs-they did. But, the big range and run dogs were just better.
My dogs are about 85% pet, and the rest is weekend warrior hunting dog. They usually lack a little polish (example, I don't break them to wing and shot, as I prefer them to be heading in the direction of the bird I just shot at, especially pheasants) and while I owned a superb grouse and pheasant dog at one time in my life (the Gordon) truth be told, good grouse dogs are hard to find, way harder to find then good pheasant dogs. My last English had roosters pretty well figured out, but, never really caught on with grouse.
As you might imagine, that is just the tip of a very big iceberg, and I bet fist fights have developed over differences in opinion on good and not-so-good dog work.
A very good book I can recommend on all aspects of the setter experience, is "The Field Gordon Setter-The Black and Tan Bombshell" by Suzanne and Norman Sorby. It is my bible on training and all other aspects of living with dogs, and transfers well to other hunting/pointing breeds. The airline lost your pooch on a flight? This book will tell you where and how to start looking.
It may be out of print, but, Mr. Sorby recently passed away, and I heard a rumor it might be printed again. It is well worth finding.
I've heard some bad-mouthing of the Sorby's over the years, always from people who weren't as successful with their dogs as he was with his. Mr. Sorby held an advanced degree in nuclear physics, and ran a particle accelerator at one point in his life, and walked away from it to work and breed his dogs.
He may have been the most intelligent man I've ever known.
Hope this helps.
Best,
Ted