al:
As some have suggested, there certainly is a cadre of "up and coming gunsmiths." I have no personal experience with any of those mentioned. But I am sure they satisfy the needs of many who seek "exceptionally good work with quick turn around time."
However I, for one, find that stipulation an oxymoron. In my somewhat jaded experience, the cannons of "exceptionally good" directly conflict with "quick turn around." It's like the old bromide; "Good, Fast, Cheap... Pick One."
Of course, this all depends upon one's definition of "exceptionally good." Mine might be different than yours. Or that of other posters on this site.
I'm sure the young men previously cited are fine workmen. But I'd personally put my trust in the "booked up for months" fellows if my gun were worth a farthing. Just my observation. Which, I'm sure, will soon be shredded by others.
Best, Kensal
Just my thoughts on this, but if a gunsmith charged you for the time he held your gun, you could buy a gun factory. A job that a smith charges...say...$300 for; that could only be somewhere between 4-10 hrs work. What most of us wait extreme lengths of time for and repeated calls to the point of frustration and anger for with some (you fill in the number) gunsmiths is their "brass ring" (read that quick cash) project hopping. Once some of them get some advance cash, they're on to another. This is not unlike a home improvement contractor.
The good ones run a "first in - first out" shop policy. Like many of you, I've experienced some pretty bad examples and heard of extremes where guns have been with smiths for years, sometimes going past a decade. The best craftsman in the world, even if he charges nothing, isn't of any value to me if he doesn't get my work done. Somewhere there's a balance.