The QA case only works well if you are buying a Browning! I have both canvas/leather and all leather cases from Jeff's and at least one leather case from Browning. They are all good, and I would go with the case that is the best fit for your gun. There is lots of variation in fit among SxS, O/U, and repeaters in the various cases from both sources. The Browning cases seem to be a bit bulkier than Jeff's cases, and if you are buying a SxS then the advantage goes to Jeff's because he can sell you a compact toe-under case in canvas or leather. It might come down to which case color you prefer.
