At the sale price, the CSMC case is worthwhile. I have two that came with my RBL's and at $169 I'm tempted to buy another case, just because. When Jeff's puts the toe-under case on sale, I think that's a better buy and a nicer case. I also have a couple of those and they are extremely compact for what they hold. Jeff's toe-under cases seem to come in more sizes, both gauge and barrel length than the CSMC cases, and the cases from Jeff's fit the guns very closely, so the CSMC case might be more versatile if you want to use it for more than one gun.