RST @ $10
B&P @ $8

and then Herter's Low recoil at $6

I find the Herter's to have a much sharper recoil than the B&P.
RST has some models that I question their usefulness.

I shoot equal numbers of both Herter's and B&P each year.
I'd say the B&P F2 7/8oz 12ga is about as good a shell as there is for practice. Low recoil, low pressure, good patterns, etc.

Out there doing it best I can.