If a reloadable hull is important, the Remington Gun Club is the best choice of those listed. Reloading economics is the big problem now. The Federal Top Gun is an excellent shell in my experience - quality control being better than the Gun Club, but it isn't really a good shell for reloading.

Buy as many shells as you can afford, and do it now. $40/flat will soon be long ago and far away.

"The price of good shotgunnery is constant practice" - Fred Kimble