I would have bought the Ithaca.
The Ithaca had a xx fancy buttstock that showed a little finish added in spots...Sorry I botched the deal for Jeff...the Flues was offered to me as a Lewis for $250, when I took the gun down to show him the cocking tongue that makes it a Flues, I also noticed the 2 grade designation and told him so. His response was "does that mean it's worth more?" I said $100 bucks ao so...
..also each barrel was marked 4/4 which I assume is the choke designation for full and full. The action was beautiful except for the chicken track border engraving...The guy took my email address, I assume to help identify the rest of the collection...oh yeah, the Flues was crolle, the Crass was stub twist. Both were honest wear guns.