Another interesting comparison might be pre-WWI best guns compared to those produced today (where one might argue that CNC as well as threat of litigation plays a role). There are many who argue that the older "hand-made guns" are the epitome. Others argue these vintage guns have proven their quality by lasting so long in good condition. Whatever the basis, the pre-war bests are held up as the standard often.

However, DAC, I take it you are looking at a gun to be produced for you now and want to limit the discussion to that end.

So, why "round body" but no discussion of the Scottish guns?

BTW, I think you will find an equal number of those impressed by Watson Bros in the past couple of years to offset those who have sniffed that WB isn't quite up to the standards of the Big Three in terms of finish. Same as with the AA Brown guns really as far as I can see. But, you'd have to look at both and decide in your own mind probably because there will always be detractors. The gun market reflects a name premium in much the same way as the fine watch market...