As for waterproof, anything but rubber, is a joke. I've had numerous "waterproof" "breathable" snake boots that get soaked inside walking through dew covered grass, boots from Rocky to LaCrosse laced, zip ups.
In the early years of turkey hunting, I just went ahead and got used to having wet feet with with Vietnam era jungle boots. I couldn't wear the LaCrosse lace-ups as they aggravated plantar fasciitis in my right foot regardless if I had orthotics in them or not. If foot comfort and convenience have value beyond dollars and cents, Chameau can't be beat. They can't be left in a hot attic as they are rubber. Leather lining helps defeat moisture build up from sweat. With two pairs of quality boots, you can spend as much on boots as what a set of truck tires cost, but then you never have to rotate your feet. Gil