For real, I'm going to summarize and sign off:
Vise style:
DGJ users have a variety of vises and opinions about the optimal vise for gun work. There is broad concensus that a properly mounted, heavy bench vise is the foundation of a gunsmith's bench.
However, some tasks are better served with a small, low profile vise, and for those who restrict their work to specialized tasks, one specialized vise may be sufficient. For others, owning multiple vises may be necessary or at least expedient.
Traditional gunmakers and professional gunsmiths apparently favor blacksmith post vises or heavy duty bench vises for the majority of stock, action, and barrel work.
Makers and age:
There are two options for buying a new US made bench vise (Morgan, Wilton). And one UK made option (Record) for now. New domestic vises come at premium prices, and can be difficult to source.
Among DGJ users, there are some who are vise enthusiasts, including some with a wide variety of vises. While finding a solid, functional vintage vise can be a challenge, many DGJ users have found vintage vises meet all of their needs and add to their enjoyment of the work.
Desirable vintage brands include Athol, Reed, Parker, Starrett, Rock Island, Wilton, and others. Vise guys seem to favor Reed & Parker. Wiltons are also extremely sought after. Parker vises are made by the same company as Parker guns.
Features:
A swivel base is a necessary asset unless one can otherwise access the vise from the side or rear. A swivel jaw can be very useful but is hard to find. The vise mount is critical to the proper function of the vise. And a 'horse' is crucial for supporting the opposite end of long work, like a stock. A covered lead screw is an indication of quality and helps to maintain the vise.
Replaceable jaws are also important (but but absolutely necessary), especially if the vise is old and has been 'well-used.'
There are a variety of jaw covers. Lead, copper, brass, wood, and leather are all good options depending on the exact task.
Conclusion:
Buy the best bench vise you can reasonably afford for your 'main vise.'
Use it.
Thanks to all of you for your input.
jw
Last edited by Woodreaux; 11/19/19 10:25 PM.
